‘Yes I do.And as soon as possible, too.’
‘They’d be upset.’
‘Too bad.It’s for their own good.’ I opened my eyes and flashed what was, I hoped, a palpably contrived smile at the ship’s remote drone, which was sitting at a slightly drunken angle on the arm of the couch.Then I closed my eyes again.
‘Probably it would be, but that isn’t the point, really.’
‘What is the point then, really?’ I knew the answer too well already, but kept hoping the ship would come up with a more convincing reason than the one I knew it was going to give.Maybe one day.
‘How,’ the ship said through the drone, ‘can we be sure we’re doing the right thing?How do we know what is – or would be – for their own good, unless, over a very long period, we observe matched areas of interest – in this case planets – and compare the effects of contacting and not contacting?’
‘We ought to know well enough by now.Why sacrifice this place to some experiment we already know the results of?’
‘Why sacrifice it to your own restless conscience?’
I opened one eye and looked at the remote drone on the couch arm. ‘A moment ago we agreed it would probably be for the best, for them, if we went in.Don’t try and cloud the issue.We could do it, we should do it.That’s what I think.’
‘Yes,’ said the ship, ‘but even so there would be technical difficulties, given the volatility of the situation.They’re on a cusp; a highly heterogeneous but highly connected – and stressedly connected – civilization.I’m not sure that one approach could encompass the needs of their different systems.The particular stage of communication they’re at, combining rapidity and selectivity, usually with something added to the signal and almost always with something missed out, means that what passes for truth often has to travel at the speed of failing memories, changing attitudes and new generations.Even when this form of handicap is recognized all they ever try to do, as a rule, is codify it, manipulate it, tidy it up.Their attempts to filter become part of the noise, and they seem unable to bring any more thought to bear on the matter than that which leads them to try and simplify what can only be understood by coming to terms with its complexity.’
‘Uh right,’ I said, still trying to work out exactly what the ship was talking about.
‘Hmm,’ the ship said.
When the ship says ‘Hmm’, it’s stalling.The beast takes no appreciable time to think, and if it pretends it does then it must be waiting for you to say something to it.I out-foxed it though; I said nothing.
But, looking back at what we were talking about, and what we each said we thought, and trying to imagine what it was really about, I do believe that it was then it decided to use me as it did.That ‘Hmm’ marked a decision that meant I was involved the way I was in the Linter affair, and that was what the ship was really worried about; that which, all evening, during the meal and afterwards, slipping in the odd remark, the occasional question, the ship was really asking me about.But I didn’t know that at the time.I was just sleepy and full and contented and warm and lying there talking to thin air, while the remote drone sat on the arm of the couch and talked to me.
‘Yes,’ sighed the ship at last, ‘for all our data and sophistication and analyses and statistically correct generalizations, these things remain singular and uncertain.’
‘Aw,’ I tutted, ‘it’s a hard life being a GCU.Poor ship, poor Papageno.’
‘You may mock, my little chick,’ the ship said with a sort of fakedly hurt sniffiness, ‘but the final responsibility remains mine.’
‘Ah, you’re an old fraud, machine.’ I grinned over at the drone. ‘You’ll get no sympathy out of me.You know what I think; I’ve told you.’
‘You don’t think we’d spoil the place?You seriously think they’re ready for us?For what we’d do to them even with the best of intentions?’
‘ Ready for it?What does that matter?What does it even mean ?Of course they aren’t ready for it, of course we’ll spoil the place.Are they any more ready for World War Three?You seriously think we could mess the place up more than they’re doing at the moment?When they’re not actually out slaughtering each other they’re inventing ingenious new ways to massacre each other more efficiently in the future, and when they’re not doing that they’re committing speciescide, from the Amazon to Borneo or filling the seas with shit, or the air, or the land.They could hardly make a better job of vandalizing their own planet if we gave them lessons.’
‘But you still like them, I mean as people, the way they are.’
‘No, you like them the way they are,’ I told the ship, pointing at the remote drone.They appeal to your sense of untidiness.You think I haven’t been listening all the times you’ve gone on about how we’re infecting the whole galaxy with sterility isn’t that the phrase?’
‘I may have used that form of words,’ the ship agreed vaguely, ‘but don’t you think -‘
‘Oh, I can’t be bothered thinking now,’ I said, levering myself off the couch.I stood up, yawning and stretching. ‘Where’s the gang gone?’
‘Your companions are about to watch an amusing film I found on-planet.’
‘Fine,’ I said. ‘I’ll watch it too.Which way?’
The remote drone floated up from the couch arm. ‘Follow me.’ I left the alcove where we’d eaten.The drone turned round as it meandered through curtains and around chairs, tables and plants.It looked back at me. ‘You don’t want to talk to me?I only want to explain -‘
‘Tell you what, ship.You wait here and I’ll hit dirt and find you a priest and you can unburden yourself to him.The Arbitrary goes to confession.Definitely an idea whose time has come.’ I waved at some people I hadn’t seen for a while, and kicked some cushions out of my way. ‘You could tidy this place up a bit, too.’
‘Your wish’ the remote drone sighed and stopped to supervise the cushions, which were dutifully rearranging themselves.I stepped down into a darkened, sound-shrouded area where people were sitting or lying in front of a 2D screen.The film was just starting.It was science fiction, of all things; called Dark Star. Just before I stepped through the soundfield I heard the remote drone behind me sigh to itself again. ‘Ah, it’s true what they say; April is the cruellest month’
2.3:Unwitting Accomplice
It was about a week later, when I was due to go back on-planet, to Berlin, when the ship wanted to talk to me again.Things were going on as usual; the Arbitrary spent its time making detailed maps of everything within sight and without, dodging American and Soviet satellites and manufacturing and then sending down to the planet hundreds upon thousands of bugs to watch printing works and magazine stalls and libraries, to scan museums, workshops, studios and shops, to look into windows, gardens and forests, and to track buses, trains, cars, seaships and planes.Meanwhile its effectors, and those on its main satellites, probed every computer, monitored every landline, tapped every microwave link, and listened to every radio transmission on Earth.
All Contact craft are natural raiders.They’re made to love to be busy, to enjoy sticking their big noses into other people’s business, and the Arbitrary, for all its eccentricities, was no different.I doubt if it was, or is, ever happier than when doing that vacuum-cleaner act above a sophisticated planet.By the time we were ready to leave the ship would have contained in its memory – and would have onward-transmitted to other vessels – every bit of data ever stored in the history of the planet that hadn’t been subsequently obliterated.Every 1 and 0, every letter, every pixel, every sound, every subtlety of line and texture ever fashioned.It would know where every mineral deposit was buried, where all the treasure as yet undiscovered lay, where every sunken ship was, where every secret grave had been dug; and it would know the secrets of the Pentagon, the Kremlin, the Vatican
On Earth, of course, they were quite oblivious to the fact they had a million tonnes of highly inquisitive and outrageously powerful alien spaceship orbiting around them, and – sure enough – the locals were doing all the things they normally did; murdering and starving and dying and maiming and torturing and lying and so on.Pretty much business as usual in fact, and it bothered the hell out of me, but I was still hoping we’d decide to interfere and stop most of that shit.It was about this time two Boeing 747s collided on the ground in a Spanish island colony.
I was reading Lear for the second time, sitting underneath a full-size palm tree.The ship had found the tree in the Dominican Republic, marked to be bulldozed to make way for a new hotel.Thinking it might be nice to have some plants about the place, the Arbitrary dug the palm up one night and brought it aboard, complete with its root system and several tens of cubic metres of sandy soil, and planted it in the centre of our accommodation section.This required quite a lot of rearranging, and a few people who’d happened to be asleep while all this was going on woke to be confronted with a twenty-metre high tree when they opened their cabin doors, rising up in what had become a great central well in the acc section.Contact people are used to putting up with this sort of thing from their ships, however, and so everybody took it in their stride.Anyway, on any sensible calibrated scale of GCU eccentricity, such a harmless, even benign prank would scarcely register.