“Except that you sent him to me.”
“Well, yes,” he said, “except that, of course; but then, see, I was putting in a boost for you.” He said it seriously.
I said: “My pal.”
“How did I know he was going to blow his top? Anyways, he didn’t hurt you much, did he?”
“Maybe not, but it didn’t do me any good and I–” I stopped as the waiter arrived with the champagne. We tasted it and said it was swell. It was pretty bad. “Think he killed the girl?” I asked.
Studsy shook his head sidewise with certainty. “No chance.”
“He’s a fellow you can persuade to shoot,” I said.
“I know–these foreigners are hysterical–but he was around here all that afternoon.”
“All?”
“All. I’ll take my oath to it. Some of the boys and girls were celebrating upstairs and I know for a fact he wasn’t off his hip, let alone out of here, all afternoon. No kidding, that’s a thing he can prove.”
“Then what was he worried about?”
“Do I know? Ain’t that what I been asking him myself? But you know how these foreigners are.”
I said: “Uh-huh. They’re hysterical. He wouldn’t’ve sent a friend around to see her, would he?”
“I think you got the boy wrong,” Studsy said. “I knew the dame. She used to come in here with him sometimes. They was just playing. He wasn’t nuts enough about her that he’d have any reason for weighting her down like that. On the level.”
“Was she on the stuff too?”
“I don’t know. I seen her take it sometimes, but maybe she was just being sociable, taking a shot because he did.”
“Who else did she play around with?”
“Nobody I know,” Studsy replied indifferently. “There was a rat named Nunheim used to come in here that was on the make for her, but he didn’t get nowhere that I could see.”
“So that’s where Morelli got m address.”
“Don’t be silly. All Morelli’d want of him would be a crack at him. WThat’s it to him telling the police Morelli knew the dame? A friend of yours?”
I thought it over and said: “I don’t know him. I hear he does chores for the police now and then.”
“M-m-m. Thanks.”
“Thanks for what? I haven’t said anything.”
“Fair enough. Now you tell me something: what’s all this fiddlededee about, huh? That guy Wynant killed her, didn’t he?”
“A lot of people think so,” I said, “but fifty bucks’ll get you a hundred he didn’t.”
He shook his head. “I don’t bet with you in your own racket”–his face brightened–“but I tell you what I will do and we can put some dough on it if you want. You know that time you copped me, I did lead with my right like I said, and I always wondered if you could do it again. Some time when you’re feeling well I’d like–”
I laughed and said: “No, I’m all out of condition.”
“I’m hog-fat myself,” he insisted.
“Besides, that was a fluke: you were off balance and I was set.”
“You’re just trying to let me down easy,” he said, and then more thoughtfully, “though I guess you did get the breaks at that. Well, if you won’t– Here, let me fill your glasses.”
Nora decided that she wanted to go home early and sober, so we left Studsy and his Pigiron Club at a little after eleven o’clock. He escorted us to a taxicab and shook our hands vigorously. “This has been a fine pleasure,” he told us.
We said equally polite things and rode away.
Nora thought Studsy was marvelous. “Half his sentences I can’t understand at all.”
“He’s all right.”
“You didn’t tell him you’d quit gum-shoeing.”
“He’d’ve thought I was trying to put something over on him,” I explained. “To a mugg like him, once a sleuth always a sleuth, and I’d rather lie to him than have him think I’m lying. Have you got a cigarette? He really trusts me, in a way.”
“Were you telling the truth when you said Wynant didn’t kill her?”
“I don’t know. My guess is I was.”
At the Normandie there was a telegram for me from Macaulay in Allentown: