I was also brooding about that green mohair blanket Crystal had given Dow, about someone sitting in his lap after he’d been shot to death. You wouldn’t want to drive far. Certainly not out on public roads where a pedestrian or a driver in the next lane might look over at just the wrong moment and spot you in the dead man’s embrace. If you were the killer, you’d think about the reservoir-how nice it would be if both the dead man and the car disappeared from view. Jonah had been assuming the killer made an unfortunate mistake, miscalculating the position of the boulder, which prevented the car from being fully submerged. What if the reverse were true? Maybe the killer intended to have the car found. If Dow’s death was meant to look like suicide, then maybe the causal error went the other way. The killer knew the boulder was there and thought the car would still be visible when daylight came. Instead, the vehicle veered slightly and sank too far down to be seen easily.
It wasn’t until late afternoon that I opened my bottom drawer and hauled out the phone book, turning to the yellow pages under the section that listed painting contractors. There must have been a hundred, column after column, some of them with box ads, some with catchy sayings: DON’T PAINT YOURSELF INTO A CORNER WHEN YOU CAN LET US DO IT. CHARLIE CORNER SONS, PAINTING. I had a quick vision of the Corner family sitting around the kitchen table, tossing back shots, coming up with log lines to stretch the advertising budget.
I started with the A’s and ran my finger down the names until I found the one I remembered from Fiona’s sign out front. One line of print. RALPH TRIPLET, COLGATE. No street address. I made a note of the phone number. Fiona struck me as the sort who’d pick a lone operator, somebody too hungry for business to argue with her. She’d by-passed all the splashy half- and full-page ads.
I dialed Ralph Triplet’s number. I was going to cook up a ruse, but I couldn’t think of one.
The phone was picked up on the first ring. “Ralph Triplet Painting.” I said, “Hi, Mr. Triplet. My name is Kinsey Millhone. I just finished doing some work for Fiona Purcell up on Old Reservoir . . .”
“I hope you got your money up front.”
“That’s why I’m calling. Is she a slow pay by any chance?”
“No pay is more like it. You seen that place of hers? White everywhere. You think that’d be simple enough, but we’ve gone through six shades so far. Everything from Frost to Alabaster, Eggshell to Oyster. Couldn’t find anything to suit. I’d get half a wall up, and then she’d want something else. Too green, she’d say. Or get the pink out of it. Meantime, I haven’t been paid in weeks. The architect filed a lien against the property and I’m threatening to do likewise. Meantime, I finally got around to checking her credit. Should have done that in the first place, but how was I to know. She puts on a good show, but she’s busy using one credit card to pay off another. What’d you say your name was?”
“Doesn’t matter,” I said and hung up.
I pulled out the rubber-banded packet of index cards. This time I didn’t add anything. I shuffled back through my cards, checking the information I’d picked up in the past week, particularly the details about Dow’s last day. In passing, Mrs. Stegler had confided an item that caught my attention in light of everything I’d learned since then. She said while he was out at lunch, Fiona had stopped by. She’d waited in his office and had finally departed, leaving him a note. I’d sat in that office myself and I know how easily she could have opened his desk drawer and taken his gun.
Driving up Old Reservoir Road in the gathering dark, I could feel myself in a state of suspended animation. The only sign of agitation was that I was taking the curves a little too fast for the current road conditions, which were wet, wet, wet. I had an idea, an intuition to verify before I called Jonah Robb. I turned left on the road that angled up beside her property and pulled into the parking area behind the house.
I went around to the front door and rang the bell. She took her sweet time coming to the door. I stared off at Brunswick Lake. In the waning light, the surface was as silvery as mercury. It had been eleven days since I first stood in this spot, looking out at the same sweeping views. The steep sloping lot was now a fairyland of knee-high weeds: fox tails, wild oats, and rye bending in the passing breeze. With much more rain, the now-softened hillside would slide down into the road.
The door opened behind me. Even baby-sitting for her grandchildren, Fiona was decked out in a black wool suit with big shoulder pads and a pinched-in waist. The lapels and jacket cuffs were done in a faux leopard print. She had her hair concealed in a matching leopard print turban. Gloria Swanson had nothing on her. I held out the envelope. “I included an invoice for your records. I hope you don’t mind signing for the cash.”
“Of course not. Won’t you come in?”
I stepped into the foyer. There was a tricycle in the hall and the floor was covered with the same sort of kiddie detritus I’d seen at Blanche’s house: Tinkertoys, blocks, a sock, broken crackers, crayons. The kids had built an enormous tent with the painter’s drop cloths, which were now draped over all the chairs in the living room. I could see them bumping around in there, erupting in the sort of harsh, artificial giggles that signal the prelude to a big stinking fight.
Fiona scribbled her signature on the receipt. Her fingernails were dark red. She wore the same shade on her lips. She had a smudge of lipstick on the surface of her two front teeth. The effect was odd, like a virulent attack of bleeding gums. I tore off the top copy and handed it back to her.
“How’s Blanche doing?”
“She’s fine. At least she’s had peace and quiet for the afternoon. Andrew’s picking the kids up after supper tonight . . . assuming we live that long.”
“Mind if I use the bathroom?”
“There’s one off the kitchen. You can help yourself.”
“Be right back,” I said.
Fiona returned to the living room and I could hear her issuing orders about the cleanup. The kids even seemed inclined to cooperate.
I walked through the kitchen and unlocked the door leading into the three-car garage. It was dark outside and the yawning space was gloomy. There was a BMW parked in the nearest space, but the other two were empty. She’d told me when Dow came to visit, she made him pull into the garage each time so the local tongues wouldn’t wag. I flipped on the overhead light, which didn’t help that much.
I took the flashlight from my shoulder bag and crossed to the far wall. I imagined myself sitting in Dow’s silver Mercedes. I looked to my left and calculated the trajectory of a bullet fired from the front seat through the driver’s head, through the car window, and into the wall. Right about there, I thought. I’d have bet money she never bothered to pry the bullet out of the dry wall. She’d had enough white paint on hand to cover any evidence of what she’d done. Who’d even think to look here? The cops with their metal detectors would be scanning down the hillside as far as the road.
In the light of the faulty overhead bulb, the wall appeared to be smooth. I ran a hand lightly over the finish, expecting to feel the faintly irregular patch of plaster fill. The wall was unblemished. Not a mark anywhere. I shone the light at an angle, hoping for the roughness in the surface to jump into bas-relief. There was nothing. I made a circuit of the space, but there was no indication whatsoever that Dow had been shot to death here before the car was moved. No fragments of glass, no oil patches on the floor where his car had sat. I stood there astonished. I wanted to wail with disappointment. This had to be right. I had been so sure.
The door to the kitchen opened and Fiona appeared. She stood and stared at me. “I wondered what happened to you.”
I looked back at her, mouth suddenly dry, desperate for an explanation that would cover my behavior.
“Detective Paglia was up here earlier, doing exactly the same thing. He checked the walls for a buried bullet and found none.”
“Fiona, I’m sorry.”
“I’m sure you are.” She paused a moment. “One question, please. If I’d actually killed Dowan, why in the world would I hire you?”