Cade knew that Blair could go on for hours if he was allowed to warm to a theme. He looked over at Vrel. “I don’t know about quick and violent changes to planets, but I’ve seen plenty of them in people. This is starting to sound more like your field.” Vrel was the political economist.
Vrel raised the can he was holding, twirled it around and contemplated it for a few seconds, then seemed to change his mind and lowered it again. “Hm. There’s something paradoxical here,” he said. “Terrans believed in gradualism, but their whole history is violent and catastrophic. Hyadeans accept upheaval as the natural way of change, but we deplore it and try to eliminate it from our affairs. That’s what’s at the bottom of our problems with the Querl—why we and they are in armed opposition.”
“How’s that?” Blair asked. The reasons for the standoff and occasional conflict between the Hyadean and the Querl worlds was something that Cade had long wanted to understand better too.
“Well, we are taught that their system reflects values that are incompatible with ours,” Vrel said. “They take pride in what we consider to be social ills in need of correction. They could never conform to the system of approvals and entitlements that our social structure is built on.”
“So does that make them a threat that you have to defend against?” Cade asked.
“We’ve always been told that they are,” Vrel replied.
Krossig conceded the field to politics and elaborated. “Their system can’t work. Our economists have proved it. Because it’s based on conflicts and rivalries that consume nonproductive effort, it must devour resources faster than it can replenish them. As the situation becomes more critical, the conflicts will increase, making the imbalance worse. Eventually, the only solution left to them will be to try and take from us—provided we let them. If we make that impossible by maintaining sufficient military strength, the outcome, eventually, must be the Querl’s downfall.”
Cade drank again and stared at him. It was too pat, like a memorized line that had been drummed in through life. Typically Hyadean. He shifted his gaze to Vrel, whose response had been less automatic. Twice, Vrel had qualified his statements by cautioning that they were what Hyadeans were “taught” or had been “told.” Those were surprising words to hear coming from a Hyadean. “I assume the Querl must know the Chrysean position,” he said. “So how do they see it?”
“They don’t see themselves as disorderly or unruly, but simply as pursuing their ideals of independence and freedom,” Vrel replied. He thought for a moment, and then smiled uncomfortably. “And we’re supposed to be here to save Earth from going the same way. Yet it seems that those same things are also regarded as ideals by most humans.” He looked from one to another of the others helplessly. “Another paradox. There’s something wrong somewhere, isn’t there? But I can’t put my finger on what it is.”
Warren came out from the wheelhouse at that point to announce that they had reached the fishing grounds and were slowing down to begin casting, and Vrel’s question never did get answered. Later, when Cade and Blair were leaning on the rail together, watching the waves, Blair remarked that it was the first time he had ever heard a Chrysean questioning the home world’s system.
“I know,” Cade replied. “Interesting, isn’t it? Maybe this crazy world of ours is starting to rub off on them more than we think.” He lifted his head to follow a group of porpoises as they broke surface to frolic a hundred feet or so from the boat. “And then again . . . maybe it was just the beer.”
CHAPTER THIRTEEN
IT WAS STRANGE THAT THE THEORY Earth’s scientific establishment finally put together for shaping the evolution of the cosmos should be based on gravity, when the electromagnetic force was ten thousand billion, billion, billion, billion times stronger, and 99 percent of observable matter existed in the form of electrically charged plasma that responded to it. More so when galaxies, certain binary stars, and other objects were found not to move in the ways that purely gravitational models said they should, and various forms of “dark matter” and other unobservables had to be invented to explain why.