“What exactly did this psychic tell her?” I wanted to know.
Wesley looked levelly at me and replied, “I really can’t go into that. Not now.”
“But she discussed it with you?”
I inquired. “Pat Harvey volunteered to you that she had resorted to a psychic?”
“I’m not at liberty to discuss it, Kay,” Wesley said, and the three of us were silent for a moment.
It went through my mind that Mrs. Harvey had not divulged this information to Wesley. He had found out in some other way.
“I don’t know,” Marino finally said. “Could be a random thing. I don’t want to count that out” “We can’t count anything out,” Wesley said firmly.
“It’s been going on for two and a half years, Benton,” I said.
“Yeah,” Marino said. “A friggin’ long time. Still strikes me as the work of some squirrel out there who fixes on couples, a jealousy-type thing because he’s a loser, can’t have relationships and hates other people who can.”
“Certainly that’s one strong possibility. Someone who routinely cruises around looking for young couples. He may frequent lovers’ lanes, rest stops, the watering holes where kids park. He may go through a lot of dry runs before he strikes, then replay the homicides for months before the urge to kill again becomes irresistible and the perfect opportunity presents itself. It may be coincidence – Deborah Harvey and Fred Cheney may simply have been in the wrong place at the wrong time.”
“I’m not aware there’s evidence to suggest that any of the couples were parking, engaged in sexual activity, when they met up with an assailant,” I pointed out.
Wesley did not respond.
“And other than Deborah and Fred, the other couples didn’t appear to have pulled off at a rest stop or any other sort of ‘watering hole’, as you put it,” I went on. “It appears they were en route to some destination when something happened to make them pull off the road and either let someone in their car or get into this person’s vehicle.”
“The killer cop theory,” Marino muttered. “Don’t think I haven’t heard it before.”
“It could be someone posing as a cop,” Wesley replied: “Certainly that would account for the couples pulling over and, perhaps, getting into someone else’s car for a routine license check or whatever. Anybody can walk into a uniform store and buy a bubble light, uniform, badge, you name it. Problem with that is a flashing light draws attention. Other motorists notice it, and if there is a real cop in the area, he’s likely to at least slow down, perhaps even pull over to offer assistance. So far, there hasn’t been a single report of anyone noticing a traffic stop that might-have occurred in the area and at the time that these kids disappeared.”
“You would also have to wonder why wallets and purses would be left inside their cars – with the exception of Deborah Harvey, whose purse has not been found,” 1 said. “If the young people were told to get inside a so called police vehicle for a routine traffic violation, then why would they leave car registrations and driver’s licenses behind? These are the first items an officer asks to see, and when you get inside his car, you have these personal effects with you.”
“They may not have gotten into this person’s vehicle willingly, fly,” Wesley said. “They think they’re being stopped by a police officer, and when the guy walks up to their window, he pulls out a gun, orders them into his car.”
“Risky as shit,” Marino argued. “If it was me, I’d throw the damn car in gear and floorboard it the hell out of there. Always the chance someone driving by might see something, too. I mean, how do you force two people at gunpoint into your car on four, maybe five different occasions and not have anyone passing by notice a goddam thing?”
“A better question,” Wesley said, looking unemphatically at me, “is how do you murder eight people without leaving any evidence, not so much as a nick on a bone or a bullet found somewhere near the bodies?”
“Strangulation, garroting, or throats cut,” I said, and it was not the first time he had pressed me on this. “The bodies have all been badly decomposed, Benton. And I want to remind you that the cop theory implies the victims got inside the assailant’s vehicle. Based on the scent the bloodhound followed last weekend, it seems plausible that if someone did something bad to Deborah Harvey and Fred Cheney, this individual may have driven off in Deborah’s Jeep, abandoned it at the rest stop, and then taken off on foot across the Interstate.”