Nancy caught my attention. She seemed distracted, but not unfriendly, crossing toward the counter to pick up a side of oatmeal. “I’ll be with you in just a minute. You want coffee?”
“I’d love some.” Apparently, she wasn’t a party to the social boycott. Alice, the night before, had been friendly as well . . . at least to the point of warning me about the freeze coming up. Maybe it was just the guys who were shutting me out; not a comforting thought. It was a man, after all, who’d dislocated my fingers only three days earlier. I found myself rubbing the joints, noticing for the first time that the swelling and the bruises gave them the appearance of exotic, barely ripe bananas. I turned my crockery mug upright in anticipation of the coffee, noting that the fingers still refused to bend properly. It felt like the skin had stiffened, preventing flexion.
While I waited for service, I studied James in profile, wondering about his contact with Pinkie Ritter and Alfie Toth. As a CHP officer, he would have been removed from any sheriff’s department action, but he might have exploited his friendships with the deputies to glean information about the homicide investigation. He was certainly first at the scene the night Tom died, giving him the perfect opportunity to lift Tom’s notes. I was still toying with the possibility that he invented the walking woman, though his motive remained opaque. It wasn’t Colleen. She’d assured me she’d never visited the area, a claim I tended to believe. Tom had too much to lose if he were seen with her. Besides, if she’d been in the truck, she wouldn’t have deserted him.
The LaMotts emerged from their booth, hunching into overcoats in preparation for their departure. Vicky crossed to the counter to chat with Barrett while Rafer moved to the register and paid the check. As usual, Nancy did double duty, setting her coffee pot aside to take his twenty and make change. James rose at the same time, leaving his money on the counter beside his plate. He and Rafer exchanged a few words and I saw Rafer glance my way. James pulled on his jacket and left the restaurant without a backward look. Vicky joined her husband, who must have told her to go out and wait for him in the car. She nodded and then busied herself with her gloves and knit cap. I wasn’t sure if she was ignoring me or not.
Once she was gone, Rafer ambled in my direction, his hands in his coat pockets, a red cashmere scarf wrapped around his neck. The coat was beautifully cut, a dark chocolate brown setting off the color of his skin. The man did dress well.
“Hello, Detective LaMott,” I said.
“Rafer,” he corrected. “How’s the hand?”
“Still attached to my arm.” I held my fingers up, wiggling them as though the gesture didn’t hurt.
“Mind if I sit down?”
I indicated the place across from me and he slid into the booth. He seemed ill-at-ease, but his expression was sympathetic and his hazel eyes showed disquiet, not the coldness or hostility I’d half-expected. “I had a long talk with some Santa Teresa fellows about you.”
I felt my heart start to thump. “Really. Who?”
“Coroner, couple cops. Homicide detective named Jonah Robb,” he said. He put one elbow on the table, tapping with his index finger while he stared out across the room.
“Ah. Tracking down the stories going around about me.”
His gaze slid back to mine. “That’s right. I might as well tell you, from the perspective of the sheriff’s department, you’re okay, but I’ve heard rumbles I don’t like and I’m concerned.”
“I’m not all that comfortable myself, but I don’t see any way around it. Responding to rumors only makes you look guilty and defensive. I know because I tried it and got nowhere.”
He stirred restlessly. He turned in the seat until he was facing me squarely, his hands laced in front of him. His voice dropped a notch. “Listen, I know about your suspicions. Why don’t you tell me what you have and I’ll do what I can to help.”
I said, “Great,” wondering why I didn’t sound more sincere and enthusiastic. I thought about it briefly, experiencing a frisson of uneasiness. “I’ll tell you what concerns me at the moment. A plainclothes detective or someone posing as one-showed up at a fleabag hotel in Santa Teresa with a warrant for Toth’s arrest. The Santa Teresa Sheriff’s Department has no record of an outstanding warrant anywhere in the system, so the paper was probably bogus, but I don’t have a way to check that because I don’t have access to the computer.”
“I can run that,” he said smoothly. “What else?”
I found myself choosing my words with care. “I think the guy was a phoney, too. He might have been a cop, but I think he misrepresented himself.”
“What name did he give?”
“I asked about that, but the clerk I talked to wasn’t on the desk that day and he claims the other fellow didn’t get a name.”
“You think it was someone in our department,” he said, making it a statement, not a question.
“Possibly.”
“Based on what?”
“Well, doesn’t the timing seem a tiny bit coincidental?”
“How so?”
“Tom wanted to talk to Toth in connection with Pinkie Ritter’s death. The other guy got there first and that was the end of poor old Alfie. Tom was a basket case starting in mid-January when Toth’s body turned up, right?”
“That’s Selma’s claim.” Rafer’s manner was now guarded and he started tapping, the tip of his index finger drumming a rapid series of beats. Maybe he was sending me a message in Morse code.
“So isn’t it possible this is what Tom was brooding about? I mean, what else could it be?”
“Tom was a consummate professional for thirty-five years. He was the investigating officer in a homicide matter that I would say, yes, captured his interest, but no, did not in any way cause him to lie awake at night and bite his nails. Of course he thought about his work, but it didn’t cause his heart attack. The idea’s absurd.”
“If he was under a great deal of stress, couldn’t that have been a contributing factor?”
“Why would Toth’s death cause him any stress at all? This was his job. He never even met the man, as far as I know.”
“He felt responsible.”
“For what?”
“Toth’s murder. Tom believed someone gained access to his notebook where he’d jotted down Toth’s temporary address and the phone number at the Gramercy.”
“How do you know what Tom believed?”
“Because that’s what he confided to another sheriff’s investigator.”
“Colleen Sellers.”
“That’s right.”
“And Tom told her this?”
“Well, not explicitly. But that’s how the killer could have found Toth and murdered him,” I said.
“You still haven’t said why you suspect someone from our department.”
“I’ll broaden the claim. Let’s say, someone in law enforcement.”
“You’re fishing.”
“Who else had access to his notes?”
“Everyone,” he said. “His wife, his son, Brant. Half the time, the house was unlocked. Add his cleaning lady, the yard man, his next-door neighbor, the guy across the street. None of them are involved in law enforcement, but any one of them could have opened his front door and walked right in. And what makes you so sure it wasn’t someone in Santa Teresa? The leak didn’t necessarily come from this end.”
I stared at him. “You’re right,” I said. He had a point.
The tapping stopped and his manner softened. “Why don’t you back off and let us handle this?”
“Handle what?”
“We haven’t been entirely idle. We’re developing a lead.”
“I’m glad to hear that. About bloody time. I hate to think I’m the only one out here with my ass on the line.”
“Cut the sarcasm and don’t push. Not your job.”
“Are you saying you have a line on Alfie’s killer?”
“I’m saying you’d be smart to go home and let us take it from here.”
“What about Selma?”
“She knows better than to interfere with an official investigation. So do you.”
I tried Selma’s line. “There’s no law against asking questions.”
“That depends on who you ask.” He glanced at his watch. “I got Vick in the car and we’re late for church,” he said. He got up and adjusted his coat, taking his leather gloves from one pocket. I watched him smooth them into place and thought, inexplicably, of his early morning arrival at the emergency room; freshly showered and shaven, nattily dressed, wide awake. He looked down at me. “Did anyone ever fill you in on local history?”
“Cecilia did.”
He went on talking as if I hadn’t spoken. “Bunch of convicts were shipped to the colonies from England. These were hardened criminals, literally branded for the heinousness of their behavior.”
“The ‘Nota’ of Nota Lake,” I supplied dutifully.