“Damned aborigines cut them to pieces,” he said after a long moment. “Cost them a lot of casualties at first, but then they swarmed right over the Hathori. Butchered them one by one. I doubt we got one in twenty of them back alive at the end, but that wouldn’t have happened against the damned Romans. Those aren’t just warriors—they’re demons that carve up anything they run into. So it occurred to me that what we needed were Romans of our own, and I managed to convince my creche cousin to convince his sector commissioner to speak to the guild masters for me. I needed all the help I could get, thanks to the Sharnhaishians and their Romans. Of course, it helped that by then they’d done the same thing to dozens of other guildsmen, and not just in our guild, either. So they gave me a chance to reclaim my career if I could find where the Romans came from, get past the Council ban, and catch us some Romans of our own. And I did it, too.”
This time his slap managed to connect with the table top again, though it was still soundless, and he threw himself untidily back in his chair.
“But we’re not Romans,” Sir George pointed out after a moment. He was half afraid to say another word, for if the Commander remembered any of this conversation—and realized all he was letting slip—at a later date, there would be one very simple way to rectify his error.
“Of course not,” the Commander said. “Good thing, too, in a way. It surprised me, of course. I never expected to see so much change on a single planet in such a short period. Couldn’t have been more than eight or nine hundred of your years between you and the Romans, and just look at all the differences. It’s not decent. Oh,” he waved a hand again, “you’re still primitives, of course. Haven’t changed that. But we got there in just the nick of time. Another five or six of your centuries or so, and you might actually have been using true firearms, and we couldn’t have that. Unlikely, I admit, but there you were, already experimenting with them.” The Commander eyed Sir George. “I have to wonder how you stumbled on the idea so soon. Could the Sharnhaishians have slipped up and suggested it to you?”
“The idea of `firearms’?” Sir George frowned.
“Pots de fer, I believe you call them,” the Commander said.
“Fire pots?” Sir George blinked in genuine consternation. “But they’re nothing but toys, Commander! Good for scaring horses and people who never encountered them, perhaps, but scarcely serious weapons. Even bombards are little more than noisy nuisances against anyone who knows his business! Why, my bowmen would massacre any army stupid enough to arm itself with such weapons. Crossbows are more effective than they are!”
“No doubt they are—now,” the Commander replied. “Won’t stay that way, though. Of course, you’ve still got another thousand years or so to go before anyone develops truly effective small arms. Still, I suppose it’s a fairly good example of why they passed the Prime Directive in the first place. If the Sharnhaishians hadn’t somehow contaminated your world, you never would have come up with gunpowder at all—not so quickly.”
He took another deep swallow, and Sir George decided to stay away from the question of where gunpowder came from. He himself knew only a very little about the subject—such weapons had become available in Europe only during his own lifetime and, like most of his military contemporaries, he’d had little faith that they would ever amount to much as effective field weapons. Certainly such crude, short-ranged, dangerous devices would never pose any threat to the supremacy of his bowmen! Yet the Commander seemed to find their existence deeply significant and more than a little worrying. It was almost as if the fact that humans had begun experimenting with them was somehow threatening, and Sir George had no intention of suggesting that the Sharnhaishians hadn’t had anything to do with the development. Besides, how did he know the rival guild hadn’t?
“Anyway,” the Commander said, the words more slurred than ever, “it’s a good thing we found you when we did. Couldn’t have used you at all if you’d been armed with firearms. Would’ve been a clear violation of the Prime Directive, and that would’ve gotten questions asked. People would’ve noticed, too, and the Council would start asking questions of its own.”